Tight Fit 2008 Contest - PHASE 2 is on page 8

[Oscar]

PHASE 2
As disclosed, phase 2 is here today!
What is phase 2? Well, you will be rated by your peers! Only the 7 people that submited are allowed to send the ratings of the coasters posted in the link below. There are 7 entries.

Your duties:
Disqualify anyone who did not follow the rules posted throughout this topic. State what rule is broken to disqualify them.
If there are g spikes above what the limits were stated, screenshot them and send them to me at the email address you submited your entry to.
Rate it as in the exchange: BT,A,O.
Provide a detailed explanation of the rating given.
You will not rate your track. Simply skip it.

That is the reason why you were not allowed to post NLDC pages or anything that would give away which track belongs to you. I did my best to remove the info on load and info posted within that would identify you. This means that the other participants will not discriminate against you.
The due date for the ratings is Friday 9pm, pacific standard time, if everyone sends in their ratings before then, I'll post results before then.

http://www.coastercrazy.com/users/wws/tf08.zip

Let the brutal rating begin!

they are all bad

Oscar, just to make it clear, you did say front seat and back seat at 100% for testing, right? .......I saved our convo XD
I Just wanted to make it clear.......
And Oscar, I like the new idea of rating, it's kinda like a private exchange.
This will be interesting

Also, I'm not rating just yet cause I dont have the time right now cause I'm going to Knobles tommorow and need some sleep, but heres a comment:

Whats with Track 1 being totally tunneled? Its not very fun being confined like that....

Also:
I reccommed everyone that is rating also rates their own track cause not rating your own would be like saying "HEY! Heres my track!!!"
Or...
Do we send the ratings in to you?

[Oscar]

I said send the ratings to the email address where yo submitted your tracks to.

Originally posted by ianko66
Whats with Track 1 being totally tunneled? Its not very fun being confined like that....

Just rate it like it's not tunneled......
(remove the tunnel)
(was that so hard to figure out?)

Btw, why are all rides except 1 and 6 so friggin' slow?

[Oscar]

Looks like I made some mistakes in the zipped file. Don't rate now and wait till I upload a second zip file.

erm, oscar, there are so many G spikes, the amount of screen shots just in track 1 it would take to show them all, could i make a movie showing them all and post you that?

[Oscar]

just 2-3 screenshots is enough proof.

ok then

edit: in what form should we send the ratings?

if the tracks are D.Q'ed do we still have to give a full rating?

[Oscar]

yes, however, like I mentioned several posts ago, there is an error in the zip file so you should wait till I have sorted it and upload a correct one.

yeah but just questions which need answering

and if we do theres no way i can get them done by friday night

I would like to know about rating DQed tracks too, Gazag.
But I bet we still should cause Oscar is just taking off points for some rule-breaks and DQing for others.

Originally posted by Adrenaguy


edit: in what form should we send the ratings?

Rate it as in the exchange: BT,A,O.

Originally posted by Rolling Coaster


Btw, why are all rides except 1 and 6 so friggin' slow?

Well just the fact that track 1 and 6 pull too many g's multiple times should answer your question.

[Oscar]

gazag, correct, the deadline will be extended

form to submit, bt,a,o format in ms word, text file, wordpad is fine.

thats what i meant by what form

so we need not rate until you post the correct zip?

ok oscar, i shall wait for the correct zip file [;)]

Can the rule be extenden until July 1st? That would come in very handy.

Originally posted by Rolling Coaster

Can the rule be extenden until July 1st? That would come in very handy.

huh?!?! [confused]

its already july 10th!!!

rolling coaster's got the skillz, he can go back in time! i think he means august the 1st, which would be handy, i come back from IOW on the 27th so you could even do them then, but meh i don't mind

[Oscar]

-you need not rate till I upload the right zip, which will be today, but if you start rating, it's to your advantage as I will indicate which tracks have been corrected

-Rule will not be Extended to July1 nor August1 but will be extended to July 18

[Oscar]

Phase 2 File Corrected:
http://www.coastercrazy.com/users/wws/t ... rected.zip

That's the correct file.
The corrected files are entry1.nltrack and entry2.nltrack
All other files remain the same.
Let me know if yo have any problems. When sending images, convert them to jpeg format or stick them in a zip file.

dunnit. didja get it oscar? oh crap the zip with all the blatant G killing-ness, ill get it to you right away!

[Oscar]

so when are we going to find out the results

[Oscar]

When everyone sends in their ratings.