Basically I own GH3, GH:WT and RB 1 and RB 2. My verdict is RB2 the clear winner. Why?
Well, for one I just beat the Guitar Tour on Expert in a little under 3 days and I played maybe...1 hour each day? It was too easy. The last song is increadibly crazy but I expected that. But Im very disappointed in the setlist. There are VERY few songs I even knew and even fewer I liked. The guitar is AWESOME but the game itself is poor by GH standards.
RockBand has the potential (if you pick up a used copy of RB1 for probably...10 bucks + 4 dollar liscense fee) to include something like 200 songs for virtually nothing by comparison. Plus the amount of downloadable content just dwarfs GH and the content is mostly GOOD! Not crappy. You can try and compare the drum sets, but remember that the Rock Band drums (the new set) have expansions for I think up to 3 symbols. So you can have a 7 peice kit instead of a 5 piece for a ton of realism. I havent used the new RB Guitar but it looks and reviews make it sound VERY solid. If you are that serious about drums though, you should just drop the 300 bucks and get the Ion Kit.
I dont know, RB2 has the challenges which is its form of "tour" which doesnt take long either but the actual World Tour part I feel like RB's is structured a hundred times better and also plays a hundred times better.
To those who cry about RB's notes being harder to hit - I find no difference. I can play both equally as well so stop your cryin and just play. The hammer ons feel identical too.
GH also feels SO childish. The characters all still look so teeny bobber. The only good models are the real people. Everything else looks so cheesy. The sets are still cheesy too. Whats up with the last level? Being pulled through the sky on a wooden ship by 4 golden eagles the size of malls? Come on now...
I guess overall the song creator is cool but too limited. GH just gave me a super case of being underwhelmed. I expected so much more from a franchise that claimed to still be ahead of the curve but I feel they have finally slipped behind RB2 and RB2 has a firm hold on the future with the amount of content and the way you can play the HUGE world tour as a single player and not be locked into the same setlists. Plus youve got the random sets on RB which is fun because you never know if taking the chance on a challenge will work or not. Ya know, being asked to get 5 stars and double your fans or lose your fans? I like that element.
I loved GH. Like everyone else, grew up on it. But really the content in RB is better, it plays the same as the new GH:WT and considering I have like 300+ songs because of DLC and the RB1 game...you cant beat that. And with the addition of the Ion Drum Kit or the new perifs with expandable options - you get the best of everything.
Yup Im an RB fanboy now. But I gave GH a fair shot and actually had high hopes. But they were flattened when the game ended and I was totally taken off guard. I should never have that happen in a game. I should know the end is near - not be suprised by it. That ruins a game and makes it feel so short.
Ill stop ranting. I was just a little agitated at how easy and quickly it ended.