2011 NLT - Round 1 [Scores pg 13]

[hyyyper]

Only one left for me, I hope to finish it tonight.

[Coasterkidmwm]

I told Oscar I'd donate 100 bucks to the site if I didn't finish by midnight tonight (central time so I gotta get cracking)

Remember what I said about how I wasn't going to get carried away with the length of my ratings this time? Well, apparently I was just kidding myself by saying that. With 50% of the ratings done, My average rating length is 743 words thus far.

[hyyyper]

My ratings are done. What I need to now is get them from 20 sheets of paper with terrible handwriting in a text file, and while I do that, here are some stats:

Of the 19 tracks, 3 are DQ'd. Reasons for those DQs were:
Support out of template
Brake section out of red area
Ride lenght too long

The highest score is a 8,67, the lowest a 4,33. The average is 6,48 .

Because of the low amount of entries, a round will be skipped. This means that the top 8 will continue for a match-up round, and after that 4 members will compete in the finale.

By the way, hyyyper, I'm not familiar with the new anonymous-track multi-judge rating system. Exactly what do I need to do in order to send my ratings in, and how will the winners be decided between the three of us?

[hyyyper]

When you (and CKMWM) are done, simply a list of all the scores to me. The final score with 1/3 mine, 1/3 yours and 1/3 CKMWM.

Also send in a text file with all the completed ratings so I can post them as soon as Oscar reveals the builder's identities

is it time to find out who is moving on to round 2
so only 3 rounds this year
not 4..?

[Coasterkidmwm]

No, give me a day or two. I know I keep delaying this but school is being a whore.

Rating a ton of tracks like this takes time.

I'm running behind schedule as well. I was planning on having them done today, but it's not looking like that's going to happen. I'm writing way more than I wanted to.

PROGRESS UPDATE:

Schoolwork caught up with me, and I had to take a break from ratings to write 2 papers. So I'm not going to be able to pick the ratings back up until at least tomorrow night, and I didn't get anywhere near as far as I wanted to. Here's my updated list of ratings:


RATINGS:

Coaster A
Coaster B
Coaster C
Coaster D
Coaster E
Coaster F
Coaster G
Coaster H
Coaster I
Coaster J
Coaster K
Coaster L
Coaster M
Coaster N
Coaster O
Coaster P
Coaster Q
Coaster R
Coaster S

White = Rating Not Finished
Orange = Rating In Progress
Red = Rating Completed

Done yet?

*Prepares for excuse after excuse

^I'm still in the same place I was on Monday. I've been booked with school work all week.

My next open time slot for ratings is Friday afternoon/evening, and I absolutely plan on having them done on Saturday. And unlike before, where I was just speculating on possibilities, this is an official completion promise. My ratings WILL be done on Saturday.

See you then!

any new news for today.. since it is 4pm here in fl

[hyyyper]

So, my body has decided to become ill. And the first thing I'm going to do when I'm better is catch up on school stuff. So it make be another week, tops

Another week= judging lasts longer than actual contest.

Wow, unreal

Ok, due to people bitching here, we will lock this for now. Hyyyper or Oscar can re-open this when the judges are done. Be grateful we even do this every year.

[hyyyper]

Here are the scores from the three judges. The top 8 tracks with the highest average scores will move on to round two. The green cells indicate the top 8 of the individual judges.

As soon as Oscar reveals which track belons to who, the judges will post the full ratings

As for the DQ's, there were three of them, below are the reasons for the DQ
G: Support out of template
H: Lift out of red area, maximum lenght exceeded
O: Brake section out of red area



Image Insert:

62.9 KB

Woo hoo! *desperately hopes track E isn't mine*

.03

[Coasterkidmwm]

Wow this is pretty much the first time I've been more generous than other people with ratings....ever.

Yeah, I was really nitpicky this time. That's why my reviews are so long. There was always at least one thing to complain about. I only gave out one score over a 9 in this whole contest.

In general, though, I'm quite happy with the correlation. There were only 2 or 3 tracks that the three of us disagreed on.


Here's the tracks grouped by the order that each judge placed them in:

Code: Select all

#---hyyyper---cjd---Coasterkidmwm---Final
1. --- P ----- C ----- C ---------- C
2. --- C ----- B ----- F ---------- F
3. --- F ----- M ----- M ---------- M
4. --- M ----- F ----- L ---------- P
5. --- J ----- J ----- B ---------- J
6. --- L ----- L ----- J ---------- L
7. --- K ----- P ----- I ---------- B
8. --- N ----- S ----- P ---------- N
9. --- A ----- N ----- D ---------- A
10.--- B ----- A ----- R ---------- K
11.--- D ----- K ----- A ---------- D
12.--- R ----- D ----- N ---------- R
13.---(G)----- Q ----- K ---------- I
14.--- I ----- R ----- S ---------- S
15.--- S ----- I -----(O)----------(G)
16.--- E -----(G)----- E ---------- Q
17.--- Q ----- E -----(G)---------- E
18.---(O)-----(O)----- Q ----------(O)
19.---(H)-----(H)-----(H)----------(H)


And here's each track and how it was rated by each judge:

Code: Select all

Tr---hyyyper---cjd---Coasterkidmwm---Final
A. --- 9 ----- 10 ---- 11 --------- 9
B. --- 10 ---- 2 ----- 5 ---------- 7
C. --- 2 ----- 1 ----- 1 ---------- 1
D. --- 11 ---- 12 ---- 9 ---------- 11
E. --- 16 ---- 17 ---- 16 --------- 17
F. --- 3 ----- 4 ----- 2 ---------- 2
G. ---(13)----(16)----(17)---------(15)
H. ---(19)----(19)----(19)---------(19)
I. --- 14 ---- 15 ---- 7 ---------- 13
J. --- 5 ----- 5 ----- 6 ---------- 5
K. --- 7 ----- 11 ---- 13 --------- 10
L. --- 6 ----- 6 ----- 4 ---------- 6
M. --- 4 ----- 3 ----- 3 ---------- 3
N. --- 8 ----- 9 ----- 12 --------- 8
O. ---(18)----(18)----(15)---------(18)
P. --- 1 ----- 7 ----- 8 ---------- 4
Q. --- 17 ---- 13 ---- 18 --------- 16
R. --- 12 ---- 14 ---- 10 --------- 12
S. --- 15 ---- 8 ----- 14 --------- 14

So, yeah, the only ones that we had differing of opinions on were B, I, and S.

There is a god!!! Now let's see whose track is whose.

yea...
whose track is whose
and can we download the winning tracks from here
would like to see some of these euro fighters