Un Fair Reviews and Acusations

hey all i think i was reviewd Unjustly, (not rated per say but his review "thoughts") were way out of line. (lied on every subject he brought up > with the exception of my LIM use).

Read his review below.

k heres the problem first your lift hill is so messed up and too many lims are used. Plus I dont think that those supports that were custom werent yours. You probly just took them from someone else. I know this because no one puts supports on the station! Try again, your own coaster would be nice too!
Technical: 1.5 Adrenaline: 1.5 Originality/Acc.: 1.5 Average: 1.50

a quote from the above reviewer

Redoing SOMEONE ELSES is stealing it unless you start and end with your supports and your track and your terrain, Im not being mean but I bet you can make a great track by starting out on your own not someone elses. Good luck, best wishes!

I actualy only posted my coaster (not for a rating) but for Reviews (which i assumed were Constructive Critisim). I Honestly wish to improve my building Techniques. I tried to post a Conter Review (no ratings) but it wont let you review your own coaster(smart) so i clicked on his link and emailed him, i got a quick reply. that just was more Acusations. I replied asking him for info (ie links to a coaster that he claims i stole) or (how do you steal suports ?)..

All im asking for is a Fair Review with Constructive Critisim... Something i can read(hopefuly many differant oppions on my track) and sit down and see if i can fix any issues.

so could any that has a chance please go test my coaster and give Real Input back please http://www.weeweeslap.com/track_exchange/detail.asp?tid=4831

okay, i saw your ride, and although he did accuse you of stealing someone's ride, i dont think the ride is worth much more than that rating gives. i dont have time to give a review now, but i will some time today

how can you steal someone else's supports? I'd love to be able to save my OWN support structures, but can't find a way!

Originally posted by cyrus1469

so could any that has a chance please go test my coaster and give Real Input back please http://www.weeweeslap.com/track_exchange/detail.asp?tid=4831

I posted a "rating" on your track, it should help you on making your next ride a bit better [:)]

Also the user who is accusing you of stealing is not really clever, because in the first place there is no problem re-creating someone elses support work. (nobody ever accused me of stealing when I made hyper supports on my tracks... I also recreated them to learn myself how to do it...) And then stealing trackwork as bad as this (no offense) wouldn't be a real smart choice either. So just think with more common sense then someone else and draw your own conslusions if someone's rating is wrong or right.

edit: i got rid of that "very" helpfull comment of him.